The new GLOCK Practical/Tactical (P/T) guns, Models
34 and 35, are a definite change of direction for GLOCK,
which has been downsizing its guns for the past few years.
Why now go upstream? Simple. There's a need for a
slightly longer version of the Model 17 (9x19mm) and
the Model 22 (.40S&W), which was not filled by the previous
long-barreled GLOCK Models 17L (9x19mm) and 24 (.40S&W).
The P/T guns have 5.32-inch barrels with matching 8.15-inch
slides mounted atop the frames of the standard Models 17
and 22 pistols, which have barrels that measure 4.49 inches.
The 5.32-inch barrel and 8.15-inch slide length give the guns
the muzzle 'feel" of a 1911. As a comparison, measuring a
WWII 1911A1, the slide is 7.5 inches long with a 5-inch barrel.
The P/Ts are slightly but not overly muzzle heavy. Magazine
capacity is 10 rounds, of course, unless you have preban
mags or are in law enforcement.
The weight, fit and balance of any handgun is very personal
to the shooter. What fits one individual will be awkward
to another. After working extensively - for too many years
to think about - with a 1911, drawing from a holster, and
then switching over to the standard-sized GLOCKs, I find
that my muzzle goes right up past my aiming point unless
I make a conscious effort to stop it, for the standard GLOCK
guns don't have that extra bit of forward weight to which
I've become accustomed with the 1911. As an aside, I don't
have this problem with the Compact Model G19 (9x19mm),
Model 23 (.40S&W), G29 (10mm) or the G30 (.45ACP). I tried
the Model 17L and the 24 and the problem corrected itself,
but then I found that the guns were just a little too long
to effectively draw without bringing them up too high during
the draw stroke. I also felt that there was too much slide
and gun hanging out front, moving around when I was
shooting.
The distance between front and rear sights on the new
P/T guns measures 7.32 inches. The WWII 1911 A1 measures
5 inches and longer on most custom 1911s, since the rear
sight is usually moved further to the rear. All this is subjective,
of course, but now that I've had the opportunity to shoot
both P/T guns, I find that, paraphrasing Goldilocks and the
Three Bears, "They're not too long, they're not too short,
they're just right." I feel very comfortable with both because
they're so close in balance to my 1911 s.
Accessories Considered
Other than the extended slide and 5.3-inch barrel, what
else is there that makes these guns differ from the rest
of the excellent GLOCK handguns? Well, GLOCK is equipping
both models with 3.5-pound connectors, extended magazine
releases and slide stopd and, of course, the new finger
groove frame with tactical light accessory rails on the
forward dust cover. Speaking of which, at the present
time, there are three lights under development. The
manufacturers are Insight Technology, Inc., Wilcox Industries
and Surefire, Inc. All three units slip on the rails from
the front of the frame and lock via a spring-loaded bar
that works the same as the GLOCK slide lock.
I found that installation can be easily and safely accomplished
as follows: If you draw the light or hold it with your off hand
as if it were a spare magazine, bring the light up to the gun
with your palm upward and index the rear of your palm against
the front edge of the trigger guard. This should orient the
tactical light such that it's directly at the front of the frame,
yet your fingers and hand will be beneath the gun's muzzle.
Pull back on the light and it will lock on the rails. (Chris
Edwards, GLOCK's director of training, and I worked this out
to be able to easily teach how to install the light and he's
dubbed this method "the Rauch Roll.") A good trick, courtesy
of Mark Donebergh, a GLOCK district manager, is to affix a
weaver scope mount of the appropriate diameter to the rails
and then insert a Surefire or Streamlight Scorpion light into
it. This should also work on other handguns which use the
dual-rail system, such as the Heckler & Koch and Walther P99
handguns.
For holsters, the choices are at present limited to a belt slide
of some sort. I was fortunate enough to have Tim Wegner
of Blade-Tech make up a Kydex belt slide for the standard
GLOCK frame so that I could interchange it among my G17,
22 and 23. (For those of you who already have belt slides
for the GLOCKS, you may find that the holster is tighter
when the new GLOCKs with the light rails are carried. The
dust cover has been slightly widened and also flattened on
the bottom of the dust shield to better stabilize the tactical
lights when attached.)
Trigger Options
The trigger pulls on both guns were very good. I like the
longer sight radius, as my eyes aren't what they used to
be and the longer the barrel and sights, the better. I've
installed 3.5-pound connectors in other GLOCKs and the
actual trigger pull, measured on a Chatillion trigger pull
gauge, read out at over 5 pounds. This is, for me, fine
for competition, but for self-defense, GLOCK will sell or
install the standard 5.5-pound connector or the New York
or New York Plus connectors. This will bring the real
measured pull to eight or more pounds.
Where will these guns find a home? To start, there are
two practical competition venues: theInternational Defensive
Pistol Association (IDPA) and the Practical and Limited
Classes in the International Practical Shooting Confederation
(IPSC). Both organizations have established a "box" rule.
For a particular gun to be permitted to be used in competition,
the gun, with magazine installed, must fit inside a certain
size box. For IDPA, the box measures 8.75 x 6 x 1.63 inches;
for IPSC it's 8.858 x 5.906 x 1.772 inches. The P/T guns fit
in both.
Another advantage of a longer barrel in .40S&W is that it
helps shooters in the "Major' power category in IPSC. (IPSC
divides calibers into two classes, Major and Minor. The
relative standings are determined by multiplying the bullet
weight in grains by its velocity in feet per second and dividing
the result by 1000. Those rounds that exceed a numerical
rating of 175 are Major and those that exceed 125 but do
not reach 175 are considered Minor.)
Although reloaded ammunition voids all factory warranties,
including GLOCK's, due to the amount of ammunition consumed
in both competition and practice, shooters of either discipline
reload. Trying to achieve the Major rating with a GLOCK
Model 22 (.40S&W) with its 4.49-inch barrel stretched or
exceeded safe pressures and a few shooters have had
their guns involuntarily and suddenly disassemble themselves
while firing reloads in this quest. With the Model 24 (.40S&W)
and a barrel length of 6.02 inches, this wasn't a problem.
It just didn't catch on with the shooters and now, with the
Box Rule, the Model 24 won't fit, eliminating it from the
game or the class.
Long Barrels & Law Inforcoment
Backing up a bit, for those of us who are old enough to
remember, lawmen - who used to carry revolvers - favored
the longer-barreled guns. For years, the Los Angeles (CA)
Police Department carried 6-inch barreled Smith & Wesson
revolvers chambered for the .38 Special. The New York
State Police carried Colt 5.5-inch revolvers chambered for
the .45 Colt cartridge, as did the Canadian Royal Mounted
Police. Here in my home state of Pennsylvania, the State
Police used 6-inch barreled Colt .38 Special revolvers.
Many of the lawmen actually preferred a 5-inch barrel,
however, because they found the longer guns to be
awkward when seated. (This created some abominable
holsters along the way, such as the swivel holster that
was unsnapped and swiveled forward or backward when
the officer sat down and was to be resnapped into place
with a fastener when the officer stood up. This often
gave rise to the spectacle of the gun and holster swinging
fore and aft as he walked, for he usually forgot to refasten
the holster!) However, the lawmen also knew that they
got more velocity out of the cartridges with the longer
barrels and could get more accuracy with the long sight
radius.
The GLOCK models 17L and 24 are long enough to get a
good sight radius and higher velocities from the ammunition,
but also have the same seating problems. Not only do a
few tactical teams both in the US and overseas use these
models, but they also use tactical thigh holsters, so they
don't have seating or drawing difficulties.
These observations still hold true for the most part, even
today. Most strong-side belt-worn guns that have barrels
over 5 inches long are often not comfortable when seated,
or they push the holster up and the whole mess digs into
the wearer. A longer sight radius does help in accurate
shooting, though, since not all ammunition has the velocity
optimized for short-barreled handguns. (In fairness, many
of the ammo companies have done just that, as I've discovered
during chronographing sessions of the same manufacturer's
gun with a 3.75-inch barrel and a 4.5-inch barrel. Some of
the five-shot averages did not differ by 25 feet per second,
while others gained well over 100 feet per second in the longer
barrel.) The P/T guns should address these areas nicely
for most.
Thunder Ranch Stress Test
I was able to shoot both new models under what can
charitably be called "stressful conditions." Along with
my friends Chris Edwards of GLOCK and fellow gun-writer
Frank James, I attended the first High Intensity Tactical
(H.I.T) course offered by Clint Smith at Thunder Ranch in
Mountain Home, Texas. The first day, we were greeted
by Harry Fleming, our lead instructor, along with other
staff instructors at the Ranch while Clint Smith was
finishing up his own training at another school. (The best
trainers are eternal students.) After a brief introduction
to the course and other administrative duties, we got
right to it, splitting into four groups for the duration.
(Not much time is spent in the classroom sitting on your
behind at Thunder Ranch. You learn by doing and being
corrected as you perform, not by lounging in a chair.)
Quoting from the H.I.T course description: "This three-day
course is a fast-moving review of defensive handguns
skills and the application of tactics to potential confrontations.
Review to include but not limited to:
- Standard range exercises & manipulatory skills review
- Terminator tactical review & runs
- Orange Range tactical review & skills
- Vehicle defense dry & live drills
- Night fire review and tactical runs
Student requirements, 1000 rounds (500 ball mandatory).
Mandatory enrollment requirement: Thunder Ranch
Defensive Handgun #2."
Translated, the above means that Clint and his staff, after
ensuring that our gun-handling skills were up to speed,
ran us flat out on moving targets that advanced, retreated,
wobbled and disappeared and we did this using high and low
cover, advancing, retreating and moving out of the center
line of the threat, from in and around a car and doing all
these exercises in light and darkness.
This gave us a chance to work with both the gun-mounted
Insight Technology and Wilcox Industries-brand lights, as
well as handheld flashlights. I used a Surefire 6P and a
Streamlight Scorpion light. (A separate handheld light is
necessary, as you might not want to - or be able to - point
mounted light at everything in the area.) We also "cleared"
the Terminator, a shoot house, as well as the Tower, a
four-story concrete building which presents such niceties
as engaging threats while ascending and descending stairways
and clearing the corners that present themselves before
and after these obstacles - not for the faint of heart, to
be sure. By the end of the three-day course, everyone
and every gun was well-worn and well-tested. We fired
in excess of 1000 rounds each of Federal 165-grain JFP
.40S&W and CCI Blazer 115-grain JFP 9 mm ammo through
the guns and both the guns and students finished without
any permanent damage. (The guns held up much better
than we did, in fact.) There is no graduation exercise;
the entire program is the test.
The H.I.T. course is, to me, the Thunder Ranch doctoral
dissertation on handgun and tactical "gunology' as taught
at the facility. You also get to see those areas in which
you are lacking. Regardless of the level of expertise,
there's always room for improvement.
During all this, Chris, Frank and I switched off using the
new P/T GLOCKs. I had also brought along my GLOCK
Models 22 and 23 for comparison. I had no complaints with
the pointability of these guns, other than those previously
mentioned. I do find that the G23, the compact .40S&W,
does leave my liftle finger tingling after extended firing,
as the cutout in the frame is exactly where my liftle finger
falls when gripping it. This annoyance was ameliorated
with the addition of a Pearce base plate, which has a filler
at its forward edge to fill up the space on the lower front
edge of the front strap. The problem does not occur
with either the standard or the P/T guns.
All in all, the combination of the new P/T guns and the
H.I.T. course at Thunder Ranch is a defining experience,
combining a top fighting school and handgun. It does not
get much better than this!
first published in the July 1998 edition of
Guns &Weapons For Law Enforcement
|